How to Prep for & Put in a Butt Plug: The Zero‑Stress Beginner Guide

Curious about how to put in a butt plug for the first time? You’re not alone—butt plug insertion is a rising topic among beginners exploring backdoor pleasure. However, many feel overwhelmed by sizing, prep, and pressure to “get it right.”

That’s why we created this zero-stress beginner guide. From how to prep for a butt plug to how to insert one safely, you’ll learn each step with comfort and care. Proper prep, body awareness, and relaxation are the key pillars of pleasurable anal plug insertion.

Inserting a butt plug doesn’t have to be painful, awkward, or confusing. In fact, with the right mindset and a bit of guidance, it can be an empowering first experience. This guide simplifies it all— no shame, no pressure, just clarity.

What Is a Butt Plug?

A butt plug is a type of anal sex toy designed for insertion into the rectum for pleasure, training, or sensation play. Unlike dildos, butt plugs are shaped to stay in place, often with a flared base for safety.

They come in many sizes, shapes, and materials from small, soft silicone plugs for beginners to weighted or vibrating options for advanced users. Therefore, choosing the right style depends on your comfort level, goals, and experience.

Inserting a butt plug can enhance solo play, intensify orgasms, or complement partnered sex. However, proper preparation and safety are essential, especially for beginners.

What Does a Butt Plug Feel Like?

Wearing a butt plug can feel full, snug, and deeply stimulating but it shouldn't feel painful. For beginners, the initial sensation is often described as a gentle pressure that gradually becomes pleasurable as the body adjusts.

The feeling depends on size, shape, and material. For example, a soft silicone plug may feel more forgiving, while firmer plugs offer more targeted pressure on sensitive nerve endings. In addition, longer wear can create a subtle awareness that intensifies arousal.

However, comfort is key. If a butt plug feels sharp, overly tight, or causes cramping, remove it immediately your body is your best guide.

What Exactly Is a Butt Plug?

A butt plug is a sex toy designed for safe and pleasurable insertion into the rectum. Unlike dildos, which are meant for thrusting, butt plugs are made to stay in place once inserted, often for extended periods.

• ● A tapered tip for easier entry
• ● A bulbous body for a full, snug sensation
• ● A flared base to prevent accidental over-insertion and allow for safe removal

Why Do People Like Butt Plugs?

People enjoy butt plugs for many reasons physical pleasure, mental arousal, and enhanced intimacy top the list. The anus is rich in nerve endings, making anal stimulation a unique source of sensation for all genders.

In addition, many users say butt plugs help them feel more in control of their pleasure, or even more connected to their partner during sex. Some like the feeling of fullness; others enjoy the psychological thrill of wearing one discreetly.

Therefore, it’s not just about stimulation it’s about exploring a new layer of your body’s pleasure map, at your own pace.

What Does a Butt Plug Feel Like?

Wearing a butt plug typically feels like a deep, internal fullness or gentle pressure—never sharp or painful when used correctly.

Here’s what to expect:

• ● Initial Sensation: A mild stretch followed by a snug feeling as your muscles relax
• ● Sustained Wear: A growing awareness that can heighten arousal over time
• ● Movement or Vibration: Additional stimulation if the plug shifts during play or includes vibrating features

Butt Plug vs. Dildo vs. Anal Beads: What’s the Difference?

When exploring anal play, it's important to understand how each toy works—and which is best suited for your goals. Here’s how butt plugs, dildos, and anal beads compare:

Feature	Butt Plug	Dildo	Anal Beads
Shape	Tapered tip, bulbous body, flared base	Straight or curved shaft, varies in size	Series of gradually sized balls or beads on a flexible strand
Function	Stays inserted for prolonged wear or prep	Designed for thrusting or penetration	Inserted and removed slowly for rhythmic stimulation
Ideal For	Beginners, warm-up, discreet wear, prostate or G-spot pressure	Intermediate to advanced anal or vaginal play	Intermediate users who enjoy build-up and release sensations
Stimulation Type	Fullness, pressure, long-term arousal	Thrusting sensation, deeper penetration	Progressive teasing, popping sensation on removal
Risk Level	Low (if flared base)	Medium (must have flared base for anal use)	Low if used gently with a sturdy retrieval loop

3 Benefits of Using a Butt Plug

Enhances Orgasm & Arousal

Butt plugs apply internal pressure to sensitive areas, which can intensify clitoral, vaginal, or prostate orgasms. In addition, wearing one during foreplay or penetration boosts overall stimulation.

Preps the Body for Anal Play

They help train the anal muscles to relax, making future anal plug insertion or penetrative sex more comfortable and enjoyable. Therefore, they’re ideal for beginners easing into backdoor exploration

Adds Psychological & Physical Thrill

For some, wearing a plug secretly in public or during sex adds a layer of mental excitement and erotic confidence. The feeling of fullness creates a unique sense of control, anticipation, and pleasure.

How to Prep for a Butt Plug (Mind & Body)

Proper preparation makes anal plug insertion smoother, safer, and more enjoyable—especially for beginners. You’ll want to prep both physically and mentally.

Mental Prep

● Let Go of Shame: Anal play is normal and valid. A confident mindset enhances comfort.

● Set the Mood: A calm, private space with dim lighting, music, or even warm towels can help you relax.

● Communicate (if partnered): Use clear consent and agree on safe words or signs to pause.

Body Prep

● Hygiene First: Shower and go to the bathroom beforehand. Cleanliness = confidence.

● Warm-Up Gently: Massage the outer anal area, or use fingers to get familiar with the sensation.

● Stretch if Needed: Some beginners use small training plugs to gradually ease tension.

● Lubricate Generously: Use a water-based lubricant—more is always better for comfort and safety.

How to Use a Butt Plug (Step-by-Step)

Prep Your Body

Start with a shower and a bowel movement—cleanliness reduces anxiety. In addition, spend time relaxing your body; tension makes anal plug insertion harder and less enjoyable.

Choose the Right Plug

Begin with a small, body-safe plug (≤ 1 inch wide) made of silicone. Avoid anything without a flared base that’s your safety anchor.

Apply Plenty of Lube

Use a water-based lubricant generously on both the plug and your anus. Reapply as needed friction is the enemy of comfort.

Go Slow with Insertion

Lie on your side or squat for easier access. Gently press the tip inward, breathe deeply, and let your body adjust. Never force it tightness means pause, not push.

Listen to Your Body

Once inserted, you should feel comfortably full not stretched or in pain. If discomfort persists, remove it and try again another time.

Play or Relax

You can use it during foreplay, solo time, or discreet wear. However, limit sessions to 20–30 minutes for beginners and always check how your body feels.

Clean & Store Properly

After removal, wash the plug with warm water and toy cleaner or mild soap. Dry fully before storing in a clean pouch or case.

Top 5 Best Butt Plugs for Beginners

Looking for the best beginner butt plug? Start with a plug that’s small, soft, and easy to insert—comfort and safety are key. Here are our top beginner-friendly picks, whether you’re going solo or exploring with a partner.

Remote Controlled Male Prostate - Butt Plug

Interactive Pulsating Remote-Controlled Male Prostate and Perineum Stimulator

• ● Perfect for: Beginner prostate play with precision stimulation
• ● Material: Body-safe silicone
• ● Size: 35° curved tip, 32mm head diameter
• ● Features: Dual stimulation (prostate + perineum), 10 pulsating modes, 10 vibration patterns, ultra-quiet (≤55dB), 8m wireless remote
• ● Why It’s Great: Designed for first-time prostate explorers, this toy delivers targeted pressure with total control and whisper-quiet operation.

Triple-Motor Anal Prostate - Butt Plug

Wearable Remote-Controlled Triple-Motor Anal Prostate Stimulator

• ● Perfect for: Users seeking hands-free, full-body prostate stimulation
• ● Material: Premium soft silicone
• ● Size: Ergonomic, wearable design
• ● Features: Triple-motor stimulation, prostate + perineum targeting, ultra-quiet (≤55dB), 8m remote control range
• ● Why It’s Great: With triple motors and a wearable fit, this is ideal for discreet pleasure and gradual prostate exploration with max intensity.

Candy Treat - Bullet Plug

Perfect for: Beginners curious about vibration with their first plug

• ● Material: Medical-grade silicone
• ● Size: Petite and rounded for easy entry
• ● Features: Built-in bullet vibrator with multiple modes
• ● Why It’s Great: Combines the safety of a beginner plug with the thrill of vibration—ideal for first-time stimulation explorers.
• B-Vibe Novice Plug

• ● Material: Premium silicone
• ● Size: Slim (1” widest point)
• ● Features: 6 vibration settings, travel lock, remote control
• ● Why It’s Great: Known for high-quality design and safety, b-Vibe is a top-rated beginner option with luxury-level vibration.

Lovehoney Classic Beginners Plug

• ● Material: Smooth silicone
• ● Size: Slim with tapered tip and strong base
• ● Features: Simple, classic design ideal for first-timers
• ● Why It’s Great: Loved for being unintimidating and easy to clean, it’s a great no-pressure way to start exploring backdoor play.

How to Choose a Butt Plug

Choosing your first butt plug doesn’t need to be overwhelming. Start by prioritizing safety, size, and shape. Always select a plug with a flared base this prevents the toy from slipping too far in.

For beginners, go for small to medium plugs (about 1 inch in width) made from soft, body-safe silicone. In addition, tapered tips make anal plug insertion smoother and more comfortable.

Want vibration or remote control? Great but choose features that suit your comfort level. Therefore, start simple, then upgrade as your confidence grows.

How to Clean a Butt Plug

Cleaning your butt plug properly is essential for hygiene, safety, and long-term use. After each session, rinse it with warm water and mild soap or a dedicated toy cleaner. Be sure to reach every curve and crevice.

If your plug is made of non-porous materials, such as silicone, stainless steel, or glass, it can be disinfected with a 10% bleach solution or boiled (check product care instructions). However, never boil toys with motors and wipe them down instead.

After cleaning, dry it completely with a lint-free cloth and store it in a clean, dust-free pouch. Never store toys while damp.

Best Positions for Inserting a Butt Plug

Finding the right position makes anal plug insertion more comfortable and intuitive, especially for beginners. Here are a few body-friendly positions that reduce tension and give you better control:

Side-Lying with Knees Bent

Lie on your side, knees pulled slightly toward your chest. This relaxed posture straightens the anal canal and helps your body stay calm and receptive.

Squatting (Supported or Freeform)

A deep squat naturally opens the hips and aligns your body for easier insertion. Use a wall or sturdy furniture for balance if needed.

Bent Over a Bed or Couch Arm

Standing and leaning forward while resting your chest on a surface allows gravity to assist and gives you full visibility and access.

Kneeling Chest-to-Bed (Child’s Pose Variation)

Kneel with your chest and arms on a pillow or bed, hips raised. This gentle, submissive position helps loosen the pelvic floor for smoother entry.

Whichever position you choose, go slow, breathe deeply, and adjust as needed. The right posture can make all the difference.

Red Flags & When to Stop

Anal play should never be painful or forceful. Watch for the following warning signs and stop immediately if any occur:

● Sharp or Shooting Pain – Indicates improper angle, too much pressure, or a plug that’s too large.

● Bleeding or Burning – Can signal a tear or abrasion. Discontinue use and allow time to heal.

● Persistent Cramping – Often caused by tense muscles or internal pressure buildup.

● Nausea, Dizziness, or Numbness – May suggest the plug is irritating a nerve or worn too long.

● Difficulty Removing the Plug – Always ensure there’s a flared base or retrieval handle.

Your body knows best. If something feels off, stop immediately, remove the toy gently, and take a break.

Choosing Between Types of Butt Plugs

There’s no one-size-fits-all butt plug. Different types offer different sensations and experiences. Here’s a quick breakdown to help you choose what suits your playstyle:

Type	What It Offers
Classic Plug	Tapered for easy insertion, flared base for safety — best for beginners
Vibrating Plug	Adds rhythmic or pulsing stimulation; ideal for enhanced solo or partnered play
Weighted Plug	Extra internal pressure and fullness; great for long-term wear and muscle training
Remote-Controlled	Partner-friendly and discreet; perfect for teasing or public play scenarios
Inflatable Plug	Can be inflated after insertion; for advanced users who want size control post-entry

Can Bullet Vibrators Be Used for Prostate Play?

Technically, no—most bullet vibrators are designed for external stimulation, not internal use. But if you’re curious about prostate stimulation, you’ll want to explore a prostate vibrator instead.

What Is a Prostate Vibrator?

A prostate vibrator is a curved, insertable sex toy designed to stimulate the male G-spot (aka the prostate), located a few inches inside the anal canal. Unlike straight dildos or plugs, prostate vibrators:

• ● Feature a curved, angled tip to reach the prostate directly
• ● Have a flared or ergonomic base to prevent over-insertion
• ● Often include vibration functions to intensify internal stimulation
• ● Some also stimulate the perineum (taint) with dual motors or external arms

Is Prostate Play Safe?

Yes if done correctly. Always use a body-safe, flared-base toy and lots of water-based lube. Start small, go slow, and listen to your body. Many men report intense, full-body orgasms from prostate stimulation.

Frequently Answer Question

How do I use a butt plug for the first time?

Start with a small, beginner-friendly plug and apply plenty of water-based lube. Choose a private, calm space and use relaxation techniques like deep breathing. Go slow, and listen to your body—never force insertion.

Are butt plugs painful?

They shouldn’t be painful when used correctly. If you feel discomfort, it may be due to tension, lack of lube, or going too big too fast. Stop and reassess before continuing.

Do butt plugs feel good?

For many people, yes. They create a deep, full sensation and can enhance arousal or orgasm. Some enjoy the pressure, others love the control or psychological thrill.

Are butt plugs safe?

Yes when used with care. Always choose a plug with a flared base, use the right lube, and clean it properly before and after use.

What does a butt plug feel like inside?

Most describe it as a gentle pressure or fullness. The sensation can become more enjoyable over time, especially when the body is relaxed and prepared.

How long should beginners wear a butt plug?

Start with 15 to 30 minutes. Let your body adjust slowly. As you gain confidence, you can gradually extend the time but always check in with your body.

Can I sleep with a butt plug in?

No, it’s not recommended. Sleeping with a plug can cause irritation, poor circulation, or injury. Always remove it before rest.

Can I wear a butt plug all day?

Not advised. Prolonged wear may lead to muscle fatigue, discomfort, or hygiene risks. Keep sessions short and safe, especially for beginners.

Can a butt plug get stuck?

It’s rare but possible if the plug lacks a flared safety base. Always use plugs designed for anal play. If it becomes stuck, stay calm and seek medical help if needed never try to force it out.